Shower vs Bathtub Resale Value: Is It Important in 2019, 2020 & 2021?

Make no mistake—remodeling your bathroom is one of the best investments you can make as a homeowner. 

There are many good reasons to renovate a bathroom. It adds storage space, improves energy efficiency, adds more functionality, and fixes any existing problems. 

More importantly, it adds to the resale value of your home. But it could also allow you the possibility of letting your furry friends get a good washing.

wet cat in the bathtub

One thing that can significantly impact your home’s resale value is having to choose between a shower and a bathtub.

It’s a tough decision to make. To let you decide, let’s go over their respective pros and cons and the ultimate throw down of shower vs bathtub resale value in 2019, 2020 & 2021, proving whether or not it is important.

Best value products

If you are remodeling your bathroom, whether installing a shower or a tub, we spent 20 hours finding THE best options for you to install in your home that will increase its value depending on whether you’re installing a value option or a high end option.

Company
Best value shower
DreamLine
Aston Avalux
Best value tub
American Standard
Woodbridge
Photo
DreamLine Cornerview 34 1/2 in. D x 34 1/2 in. W x 72 in. H Framed Sliding Shower Enclosure in Chrome, SHEN-8134340-01
Aston Avalux Completely Frameless Shower Enclosure, 42" x 36" x 72", Brushed Stainless Steel
American Standard 2391202.020 Princeton 60 in. x 30 in. Americast Apron-Front Bathtub with Right Hand Drain, White
WOODBRIDGE 71\" x 31.5\" Water Jetted and Air Bubble Freestanding Bathtub, Whirlpool Tub
Size
34 1/2 in. D x 34 1/2 in. W x 72
42" x 36" x 72"
60 in. x 30 in
71" x 31"
Professional opinion
Impressive design vs cost
Beautiful shower
Great investment
Beautiful tub for high-end home.
Best value shower
Company
DreamLine
Photo
DreamLine Cornerview 34 1/2 in. D x 34 1/2 in. W x 72 in. H Framed Sliding Shower Enclosure in Chrome, SHEN-8134340-01
Size
34 1/2 in. D x 34 1/2 in. W x 72
Professional opinion
Impressive design vs cost
Company
Aston Avalux
Photo
Aston Avalux Completely Frameless Shower Enclosure, 42" x 36" x 72", Brushed Stainless Steel
Size
42" x 36" x 72"
Professional opinion
Beautiful shower
Best value tub
Company
American Standard
Photo
American Standard 2391202.020 Princeton 60 in. x 30 in. Americast Apron-Front Bathtub with Right Hand Drain, White
Size
60 in. x 30 in
Professional opinion
Great investment
Company
Woodbridge
Photo
WOODBRIDGE 71\" x 31.5\" Water Jetted and Air Bubble Freestanding Bathtub, Whirlpool Tub
Size
71" x 31"
Professional opinion
Beautiful tub for high-end home.

Advantages of installing a shower

Thinking of installing a shower? Here are several good reasons why you should go through with it.

Require less space

They take up less space, at least if you’re going with a standard-sized stall, which measures nine square feet. A standard tub, on the other hand, takes up around 13 square feet. Big difference there!

You guessed it: you’re better off installing a shower if your bathroom is small—especially if you want to make more room for other fixtures. You can even have some wiggle room for a walk-in shower or a double vanity if you like.

Use less water

Are you always worried about your water bill? Then you might want to go with a shower instead. Think about it: did you know that using a standard-sized tub consumes between 25 to 40 gallons of water? If you think that’s a lot, wait till you use a whirlpool, which consumes between 80 to 100 gallons. 

You don’t have to worry over losing that amount of water if you’re using this option. According to Home Water Works, the average American consumes 17.2 gallons when using the shower for 8.2 minutes (the average length). Now go over the figures again and convert them to monthly (or yearly). Done? As you can already tell, the difference is staggering.

Are easier to access

Entering is an effortless thing. You just open the door (or curtain), adjust the heat regulator, pull on the nozzle, and you’re off to the races. They can also come in with grab bars, non-slip tiles, and benches, making them more user-friendly.

Stepping into a bathtub, on the other hand, requires more physical work. You have to climb in to use and climb out when you’re done. Entering one can also be dangerous for the elderly. According to a study published by the Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, a third of the elderly struggle getting in and out of the bath

Offer many features

They offer many features that make bathing more user-friendly, practical, and luxurious. Steam options, custom wallpapers, benches,  rain showers. Heck, even small tables. The point is this: with the right additions, they can offer so much more than a bathtub.

Advantages of installing a bathtub

On the other side of the argument, here are the advantages for the other side.

Are cheaper to install

If you’re on a tight budget, you’re probably better off installing a bathtub. While prices vary, a regular option can cost between $500 and $8000, while a shower can cost you between $600 and $12,000. Of course, materials and design factor into the equation. For example, a walk-in option will typically cost you $6,000 to $7,000, including labor and materials. It can reach up to $10,000 if you want one that is custom-tiled. To customize your tiles, you may want to hire a professional.

Have more resale value

They add that “special sauce” that appeals to a wide range of homebuyers. While there’s increasing interest in big, feature-heavy, walk-in models, many buyers are still likely to want one in their home. 

That’s not to say that bathrooms without ones are difficult to sell. Homes with smaller bathrooms, for starters, go better with showers. 

But overall? Potential homeowners are likely to ask, “But is there a one?” and we have to get used to it.

Safer for small children

small child in a bathtub

Stephanie Mallios, a sales rep for Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage, says that most parents want a traditional tub because it’s safer for children. Better yet, there are many ways for you to babyproof  it. You can install a non-slip bath mat made of rubber, for starters. If you’re a parent, chances are you’re worried about that spout sticking out of the wall. Thankfully, you can put a cover on it to protect your little one in case she knocks her head against it. You can also prevent your baby from scalding accidents by installing anti-scald faucets. They are also great for pets. If you’re trying to wash your dog or cat, this may be the better option.

Have more health benefits

Bathtubs offer many health benefits. In fact, studies show that taking a hot bath has health benefits similar to exercise.  Taking  a hot bath can also boost your mood, help with cold and flu symptoms, and even give your immune system the boost it needs to fight off viruses. 

To top it off, nothing beats the feeling of a relaxing bath after a long day. Throw in additives like Epsom salts, ginger, essential oils, and other additives and you get the perfect recipe for even more relaxing, soothing baths.

3/4 vs Full Bath: What gives you more value? 

We briefly discussed how significant bathtubs are for increasing a home’s resale value. Of course, the amount of features yours has is a big part of that. 

But before we proceed, let’s get something out of the way. When talking about bathtubs with home improvement companies and potential buyers, you may encounter the terms “¾ bath” and “full bath.” The confusing part is that people often mention any of these terms but are in truth referring to the other. 

To avoid any confusion, let’s do a short breakdown of what each one is comprised of.

Full Bathroom

A full bathroom is comprised of four components: a bathtub, a toilet, a shower, and a sink. Without any of these key items, a room has no right to be called a full bathroom. 

Three-Quarter Bathroom

A ¾ bath, on the other hand, comes with three of the previously mentioned components. If your bathroom consists of a toilet, a tub, a sink, then you have a ¾ bath. If you take that same bathroom and replace the tub with a shower, then you still have a ¾ bath.

So which one provides more value?

Since a full bathroom is often bigger than a ¾ bath, many would think it’s the more expensive one. In reality? Not really. The value of a bathroom, regardless of whether it’s a full bath or a ¾ bath, depends on so many factors, most notably the preferences of potential buyers. 

Most of the time, it comes down to whether a potential homebuyer prefers one or the other.

Do you need a bathtub for resale? 

Outdoor bathroom

Is it really necessary for resale? 

To give you a better idea of how a bathtub can boost a home’s resale value, let’s take a deep dive into why most potential homeowners are always on the lookout for these when buying  a new home.

A home’s resale value is mostly dependent on trends. Over the last few years, oversized walk-in showers were the rage, though many buyers still want to own one in their home. Most homeowners, particularly young families with children and homeowners with multiple bathrooms, still view tubs as a required fixture in the home. 

So, should you install one for the sole purpose of boosting your home’s resale value? 

Our answer is a resounding yes – bathtub is necessary for resale, whether you’re in 2018, 2019, 2020 or 2021. The answer is the same. However, you may want to reconsider if your bathroom is small or if you have small children. 

Does replacing a bathtub with a shower decrease your home’s resale value?

Maybe you’re done with your bathtub and want to turn it into a shower instead. But you’re hesitating because you don’t want your home’s resale value to take a dive. After all, as discussed in the previous section, a bathtub adds more to a home’s value than a shower does.

However, it also begs this question: will you be staying in that home long enough to justify replacing it? If you’ll be staying in that home for many years, why deprive yourself of the conveniences one can bring you in all that time? 

To find out if converting your tub is worth it, you may need to think of it in terms of what it will mean for your ROI (return on investment). 

You may want to think twice about going through with it if you’re selling the home to parents of small children. Why? Because a bathroom without one is a deal-breaker for most of them. As already mentioned earlier, it’s safer to bathe children in a bathtub rather than in a putting them in something where they’d be more likely to slip and fall.

In the end, the general rule of thumb is that it’s perfectly fine to replace a tub as long as there’s still one remaining in the house. Because in most cases, that one can spell the difference between a home that gets sold for a premium amount and one that does not. In fact, it’s a good idea to install a bathtub for the sole purpose of increasing the resale value of a home. 

If there’s anything that proves without any shadow of a doubt that tubs are highly valued, it’s the survey data compiled by NAHB between 2007 and 2018, which states that 70% of millennials prefer whirlpools, compared to Gen Xers with 62%, baby boomers with 47%, and seniors with 44%.

Always remember this: when you’re selling a home, you’re not just selling a bathtub, but you’re selling a lifestyle. 

Steps to Converting a Tub to a Shower

So you’ve decided to convert your bathtub into a shower? Good on you! But before you do, make sure that you know the proper procedures. Converting it into a shower is not easy, and involves a wide range of mini-projects, including plumbing, insulation, demolition, and more. But if done well, the myriad of benefits you get more than makes up for time and effort spent on the project.

The easiest way is to install one of these gorgeous prefab options, although we’ll go through the steps for a custom one underneath.

Best value, prefab options

These are great products we recommend for their value. If you’re thinking of doing anything for your bathroom, consider installing one of the ones underneath!

Company
Best value
DreamLine
Runner-up
DreamLine
Best high-end
Aston Avalux
Best design
DreamLine
Photo
DreamLine Cornerview 34 1/2 in. D x 34 1/2 in. W x 72 in. H Framed Sliding Shower Enclosure in Chrome, SHEN-8134340-01
DreamLine 32 in. D x 32 in. W x 76 3/4 in. H Center Drain Acrylic Shower Base and QWALL-5 Backwall Kit In White, DL-6195C-01
Aston Avalux Completely Frameless Shower Enclosure, 42" x 36" x 72", Brushed Stainless Steel
DreamLine French Corner 36 in. D x 36 in. W x 74 3/4 in. H Sliding Shower Enclosure in Satin Black and Corner Drain Black Base Kit, DL-6789-09
Size
34 1/2 in. D x 34 1/2 in. W x 72
32 in. D x 32 in. W x 76 3/4 in
42" x 36" x 72"
D x 36 in. W x 74 3/4 in
Material
Aluminum
Acrylic
Brushed Stainless Steel
Acrylic capped ABS
Professional opinion
Great value shower from a reputable company.
Strong contender, good value
Beautiful, modern option
Impressive, modern design
Best value
Company
DreamLine
Photo
DreamLine Cornerview 34 1/2 in. D x 34 1/2 in. W x 72 in. H Framed Sliding Shower Enclosure in Chrome, SHEN-8134340-01
Size
34 1/2 in. D x 34 1/2 in. W x 72
Material
Aluminum
Professional opinion
Great value shower from a reputable company.
Runner-up
Company
DreamLine
Photo
DreamLine 32 in. D x 32 in. W x 76 3/4 in. H Center Drain Acrylic Shower Base and QWALL-5 Backwall Kit In White, DL-6195C-01
Size
32 in. D x 32 in. W x 76 3/4 in
Material
Acrylic
Professional opinion
Strong contender, good value
Best high-end
Company
Aston Avalux
Photo
Aston Avalux Completely Frameless Shower Enclosure, 42" x 36" x 72", Brushed Stainless Steel
Size
42" x 36" x 72"
Material
Brushed Stainless Steel
Professional opinion
Beautiful, modern option
Best design
Company
DreamLine
Photo
DreamLine French Corner 36 in. D x 36 in. W x 74 3/4 in. H Sliding Shower Enclosure in Satin Black and Corner Drain Black Base Kit, DL-6789-09
Size
D x 36 in. W x 74 3/4 in
Material
Acrylic capped ABS
Professional opinion
Impressive, modern design

So, let’s get to installing a custom option, shall we? Here are the steps to converting a bathtub into a shower.

1. Decide on the size

If you’re removing a standard-sized one (60 inches long, 30-32 inches wide), you’re better off replacing it with a shower that’s roughly similar in size. This way, you don’t need to do any modifications to the wall and the shower pan. If you go with a smaller option, you will have to carry out minor repairs to the walls and the floors. On the bright side, you’re getting more wiggle room in the bathroom as a result.

2. Get the necessary permits

To ensure that you’re not violating any local laws, check with your municipality if the conversion project you’re planning on undertaking will require permits. 

3. Shut off the water supply

Is it connected to a shut-off valve? Make sure you shut it off before pushing through with the project. 

4. Remove or strip away the surround

Remove the tub surround with a pry bar and an oscillating multi-tool. If you’re having difficulties prying it off, give it a little nudge using the pry bar and a hammer. If the surround is made of plastic, it might be glued to a substrate material, in which case you need to strip it off.

5. Remove the tub

You may need to ask for assistance to do this. To remove the tub, you will need to unscrew the wall from the rim. Once it’s unscrewed, ask someone to help you lift one side and tip it over. Set it aside for the meantime.

6. Fix the studs, flooring, and joists

Once it is removed, you must repair the studs, flooring or joists that are exposed underneath. 

7. Adjust the valves and the showerhead

At this point, the water outlet and controls are positioned to service the bathtub. You need to raise both to position them for use. Typically, the valves should be located approximately 47 inches above the floor, while the showerhead is right smack dab in the center, 78 inches from the floor.

8. Install the pan

Next, you must install the shower pan. But before you do, you must set up a mortar bed for the pan to stand on. Make sure it is attached securely by screwing its lip tight to the studs.

9. Install the surround panels

It bears noting that you need to install the large back panel first when working with surround panels. Once it’s set up, install the side without the controls before doing the same with the panel on the control side. Drill holes through the controls and showerhead and then attach the last surround panel by nailing studs and caulk along the seams.

10. Install the door

Next, install the door by following the directions provided by the manufacturer.

11. Install the showerhead and the controls

Check to make sure the rough-ins are aligned with the holes in the surround panel before installing the controls and the showerhead.

12. Test it

Turn the shut-off valve back on and test if it is working.

Steps to Converting a Shower into a Bathtub

Now, what if it’s the other way around? There’s a myriad of ways to convert a shower into a bathtub, and the type of conversion you want to do will depend on many factors. But to give you some idea about the scope involved, here’s a standard procedure you can follow as you deem fit:

1. Get the area’s dimensions

The first order of business is to measure the area. You have two approaches to choose from: either you demolish the area and install a bathtub as a replacement or you modify the area so it can be converted. 

2. Check if it will fit

A standard tub measures 60 inches (length) x 30 inches (width) x 14 1/4” (height). Now, look at the area’s dimensions. Is it big enough to accommodate a standard-sized options? If not, you’ll need to carry out a demolition so that it can fit inside the area for installation. If you don’t want a full demolition, you can opt for a smaller model. 

3. Build a wall

To build the wall, cut a rectangular frame and place support boards every 10 inches along its length. Attach the frame in front and secure it by drilling long screws to the floor and adjacent walls.

3. Screw the concrete backer board into the wood frame

4. Tile the new wall

Install the first tile to the adhesive and put a spacer next to it before installing the next tile. Continue doing this until you get to the other end. Use a cutter if some of the tiles don’t fit. 

5. Apply bullnose tile pieces on the top of the wall using the adhesive

6. Start grouting

You can use premixed grout or prepare dry mix grout. Word of caution: make sure that you wear safety gear to protect your eyes and skin from grout. For best results, the rubber float must be used at a 46-degree angle to ensure that the grout is spread across the tiles and into the gaps smoothly.  Wipe away any excess grout by using a sponge.

7. Clean up

Clean the tile after the grout has hardened and then apply some water-soluble caulking along the part of the tile that meets the walls and the edge 

8. Grout it up

Wait a week before applying grout sealer on the joints and the grout lines.

6 Cheap ways to remodel a Bath for resale before selling

So, are you going with a bathtub? Or is it a shower? Or a good combination of both? Whatever your decision is, it’s worth considering what other changes you can make to improve your home’s resale value. Owning a home, after all, is a good investment. And if you’re going to make any changes, you need to know what it entails for your home’s ROI.

So, without further ado, here are cheap bathroom upgrades that will bode well for your home’s resale value down the line.

1. Install a new showerhead

If your shower head is old and outdated fashion-wise, you’re not doing your bathroom any favors. Besides, there are many “upgrades” you can do with a showerhead that both homeowners and prospective homeowners alike will find appealing. For one, current technology allows showers to maximize water flow with minimal need for water.  Some options also have added massage action to help you get rid of those tension aches after a long day at work. When it comes to these, there’s plenty for everyone, from multiple spray settings to embedded Bluetooth speakers, to anti-scald technology to water conservation

2. Reglaze or Install a New, Prefab Stall

Bathtubs & showers may accumulate chips and cracks over time. If you’re going to sell your home, you better make sure that they look good as new. You can pull this off with the help of a reglazing kit. However, it bears noting that reglazing is only for cosmetic purposes. If you want to fully restore it, call a professional plumbing contractor or a remodeling contractor (you’ll need a mobile home contractor if the bathroom is in a trailer or a camper).

There are a lot of instances where it may not even be worth it to reglaze it, but rather installing a new shower stall, as that’ll yield better results at the same price.

3. Retiling

If the bathtub is too damaged for reglazing, you can do better than to restore it, you can also change the style by retiling everything. There are many styles to choose from, including glass, marble, and metal. Allow yourself to be creative by choosing patterns and designs that showcase your personality.

4. Install a concealed shower valve

A “concealed” shower is the way to go if you want your bathroom to have a streamlined look.  Because let’s face it, exposed fittings and pipes aren’t nice to look at. Besides, they give your bathroom a more contemporary look, which will make it look more attractive to prospective homebuyers.

5. Convert yours into a steam shower

Why go to a spa if you have a steam shower right in your own home? Having one isn’t only soothing and pleasant, but it also improves blood circulation, relieves muscle tension, and removes toxins from your body. Okay, fine, converting it into a steam shower isn’t exactly cheap, as it costs between $2,500 and $6,000, but the price people are willing to pay for that added feature will more than compensate for it.

6. Install shower body sprays

Who doesn’t like a good massage? Believe it or not, you can get a soothing massage by installing body sprays in your bathroom. All you need are separate mini-body sprays that can apply water pressure across your entire body. Who needs a masseuse when you have those? Better yet, it will only cost you $500!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *